The CSCAA released the official NCAA All-American lists for the 2013-2014 season this season. In order to be considered an NCAA All-American, the athlete has to finish in the top 8 in an individual or relay event at the NCAA Championships. Honorable Mention honors are given to the athletes who finished in places 9-16 at the NCAA Championships.
| Name | Institution | Gender | Affiliation | Honor |
| Burchell, Kaylin | Alabama | Women | DI | First Team |
| McCleary, Paige | Alabama | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Caciuc, Vlad | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| Gkolomeev, Kristian | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| Hornikel, BJ | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| McKee, Anton | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| Oslin, Connor | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| Walsh, Brett | Alabama | Men | DI | First Team |
| Brandon, Bonnie | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Finnegan, Grace | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Geer, Margo | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Oder, Tjasa | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Pazevic, Alana | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Schick, Taylor | Arizona | Women | DI | First Team |
| Evans, Ashley | Arizona | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Pepper, Elizabeth | Arizona | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Sarris, Eve | Arizona | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Schoettmer, Emma | Arizona | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Amlee, Jeff | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Cordes, Kevin | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Friedemann, Mitchell | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Meyer, Michael | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Quintero, Rafael | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Smith, Giles | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Tandy, Brad | Arizona | Men | DI | First Team |
| Barber, Matt | Arizona | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Maudslien, Thane | Arizona | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Porter, Andrew | Arizona | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ricotta, Dominic | Arizona | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Stevens, Brian | Arizona | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Casper, Hailey | Arizona State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| McCormick, Riley | Arizona State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Bos, Emily | Auburn | Women | DI | First Team |
| Vitarius, Jillian | Auburn | Women | DI | First Team |
| Fonteno, Megan | Auburn | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Krakoski, Haley | Auburn | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Peacock, Aubrey | Auburn | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Purcell, Allyx | Auburn | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Chierighini, Marcelo | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Darmody, Kyle | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Disney-May, James | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Duderstadt, Michael | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Grothe, Zane | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Hancock, Alex | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Leon, Tj | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Mendes, Arthur | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| Patching, Joe | Auburn | Men | DI | First Team |
| McKean, Fraser | Auburn | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Santeiu, John | Auburn | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Fierro, Sonny | Cal Poly | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Acker, Rachael | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bing, Kaylin | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bootsma, Rachel | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Franklin, Missy | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Garcia, Marina | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Klaren, Melanie | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Li, Celina | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Osman, Farida | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Pelton, Elizabeth | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Piehl, Caroline | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Rowell, Kahley | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Tran, Cindy | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Au, Stephanie | California | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Batchelor, Sophia | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Cheng, Camille | California | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bagshaw, Jeremy | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Cox, Tony | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Fleming, Shayne | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Gimondi, Fabio | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Gutierrez, Long | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Hamilton, Will | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Katis, Chuck | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Messerschmidt, Tyler | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Murphy, Ryan | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Pebley, Jacob | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Prenot, Josh | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Stubblefield, Seth | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Tarczynski, Marcin | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Williams, Trent | California | Men | DI | First Team |
| Hinshaw, Adam | California | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Jakl, David | Columbia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Huxhold, Mitchell | CSU-Bakersfield | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zupan, Nejc | Dartmouth | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Corea, Sam | Denver | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bunch, Dylan | Denver | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Wixted, Christine | Duke | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| McCrory, Nick | Duke | Men | DI | First Team |
| Toussaint, Kira | FGCU | Women | DI | First Team |
| Svensson, Emma | FGCU | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Beisel, Elizabeth | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Hinds, Natalie | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Linn, Ashlee | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Luthersdottir, Hilda | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Mathieu, Alicia | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Russell, Sinead | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| Zalewski, Ellese | Florida | Women | DI | First Team |
| McKnight, Lindsey | Florida | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Cieslak, Marcin | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Curby, Matt | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| D’Arrigo, Mitch | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Deborde, Bradley | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Frayler, Arthur | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Homer, Christian-Paul | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Main, Corey | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Rousseau, Sebastien | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Solaeche-Gomez, Eduardo | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Wallace, Dan | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Blyzinskyj, Jack | Florida | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Elliott, Matt | Florida | Men | DI | First Team |
| Signorin, Connor | Florida | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Perez Arau, Sonia | Florida Int’l | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Britt, Chelsea | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Dressel, Kaitlyn | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Henkel, Julia | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Jacobi, Madison | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lightbourn, Mckayla | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Oliver, Tiffany | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Pochowski, Sami | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Spinazzola, Bianca | Florida State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Knight, Connor | Florida State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Murray, Paul | Florida State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Pike, Jared | Florida State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Sankovich, Pavel | Florida State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Prigge, Hannah | Fresno State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Flickinger, Hali | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Graber, Jessica | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Harrington, Lauren | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Locus, Maddie | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| MacLean, Brittany | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Margalis, Melanie | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Mattern, Jordan | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| McDermott, Amber | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Ryan, Laura | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Smoliga, Olivia | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Van Landeghem, Chantal | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Vreeland, Shannon | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Zhu, Annie | Georgia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Vernon, Nicole | Georgia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zilinskas, Rachel | Georgia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Dale, Taylor | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Fink, Nicolas | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Gemmell, Andrew | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Kalisz, Chase | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Koski, Matias | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Reynolds, Doug | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Stewart, Tynan | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Trice, Michael | Georgia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Cohen, Alec | Georgia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Freeman, Will | Georgia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Markham, Jared | Georgia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kosic, Andrew | Georgia Tech | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Mosca, Michael | Harvard | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Gismervik, Amund | Hawaii | Men | DI | First Team |
| Olanski, Taylor | Houston | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zhang, Wenting | Illinois State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Snodgrass, Brooklynn | Indiana | Women | DI | First Team |
| Vrooman, Lindsay | Indiana | Women | DI | First Team |
| Dalesandro, Gia | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Flederbach, Kaitlyn | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hillman, Kate | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Maclean, Brenna | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Pammett, Cynthia | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Pasloski, Bronwyn | Indiana | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Miller, Cody | Indiana | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ress, Eric | Indiana | Men | DI | First Team |
| Schmidt, Darian | Indiana | Men | DI | First Team |
| Schmuhl, Steve | Indiana | Men | DI | First Team |
| Abdelatif, Emad | Indiana | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Irwin, Max | Indiana | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Miller, Jackson | Indiana | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Tavcar, Anze | Indiana | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Wells, James | Indiana | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Miller, Chelsie | Kansas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bechtel, Tina | Kentucky | Women | DI | First Team |
| Cabot, Christa | Kentucky | Women | DI | First Team |
| Myers, Abby | Kentucky | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bruck, Eric | Kentucky | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ferrucci, Greg | Kentucky | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Gerotto, Lucas | Kentucky | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Greenhalgh, George | Kentucky | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lott, Chris | Kentucky | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Reinhardt, Jess | Liberty | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Weil, Cassie | Louisiana State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Greeff, Frank | Louisiana State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Worrell, Kelsi | Louisville | Women | DI | First Team |
| Brandenburg, Krissie | Louisville | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Buss, Mackenzie | Louisville | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Cottrell, Andrea | Louisville | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kylliainen, Tanja | Louisville | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| McDowell, Breann | Louisville | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Coutinho, Pedro | Louisville | Men | DI | First Team |
| De Lucca, Joao | Louisville | Men | DI | First Team |
| Blondell, Caryle | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bray, Addison | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Carroll, Trevor | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Chastain, Kameron | Louisville | Men | DI | First Team |
| Dahlia, Thomas | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lindenbauer, Matthias | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Tarasevich, Grigory | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Young, Aaron | Louisville | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Butler, Michaela | Massachussetts | Women | DI | First Team |
| McCormack, Kara | Miami | Women | DI | First Team |
| Vock, Thea | Miami | Women | DI | First Team |
| Dorman, Samuel | Miami (FL) | Men | DI | First Team |
| Nees, Zachary | Miami (FL) | Men | DI | First Team |
| Oldershaw, Marni | Michigan | Women | DI | First Team |
| Chokran, Angela | Michigan | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Deloof, Alexandra | Michigan | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Julia Fiks-Salem | Michigan | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Frost, Maddy | Michigan | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Mattingly, Zoe | Michigan | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bosch, Dylan | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Brumm, Pete | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Chen, Jason | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Funk, Richard | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Glanda, Justin | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Jaeger, Connor | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Nielsen, Anders Lie | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ortiz, Bruno | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Tafuto, Vinny | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Whitaker, Kyle | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Wojciechowski, John | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Wynalda, Michael | Michigan | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ryan, Sean | Michigan | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Janzen, Kiera | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Keefer, Margaret | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Plant, Jessica | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Simenec, Tori | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Smith, Kierra | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Votava, Lauren | Minnesota | Women | DI | First Team |
| Behrens, Tess | Minnesota | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Caflisch, Erin | Minnesota | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Harding, Sam | Minnesota | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Weiland, Becca | Minnesota | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zeiger, Blake | Minnesota | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Toomey, Derek | Minnesota | Men | DI | First Team |
| Fair, Paul | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Gordon, Ian | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Maly, Jakub | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Smith, CJ | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Turner, Daryl | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Van Swol, Kyler | Minnesota | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Barbiea, Dani | Missouri | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Doucette, Emily | Missouri | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Patterson, Anna | Missouri | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ross, Katharine | Missouri | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bonuchi, David | Missouri | Men | DI | First Team |
| Tierney, Sam | Missouri | Men | DI | First Team |
| Chadwick, Michael | Missouri | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kozlovskij, Igor | Missouri | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Mosley, Logan | Missouri | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Sansoucie, Andrew | Missouri | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Thomas, Clark | Missouri | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Duvall, Thomas | Navy | Men | DI | First Team |
| Bonnema, Riki | NC State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Grogg, Zina | NC State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Koletic, Ashlyn | NC State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Poli, Lauren | NC State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Labonge, Natalie | NC State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Nevalainen, Lotta | NC State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zevnik, Alexia | NC State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bilis, Simonas | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Boffa, Jonathan | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| McCurdy, Christian | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Schiellerup, Andreas | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Thomas, Matt | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Williams, David | NC State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Bishop, Ian | NC State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Coetzer, Stephen | NC State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Miesfeld, Barrett | NC State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Huang, En-tien | Nevada | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hoover, Meredith | North Carolina | Women | DI | First Team |
| Blalock, Carolyn | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Earp, Lauren | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hardesty, Allyn | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lincoln, Hannah | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Peacock, Stephanie | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Rechsteiner, Katherine | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Siverling, Danielle | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Smith, Carly | North Carolina | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lewis, Sam | North Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Nyquist, Jack | North Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Wilimovsky, Jordan | Northwestern | Men | DI | First Team |
| Reaney, Emma | Notre Dame | Women | DI | First Team |
| Dyer, Frank | Notre Dame | Men | DI | First Team |
| Cater, Phoebe | Ohio State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Luchansky, Katy | Ohio State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Norris, Alex | Ohio State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Schmidtke, Aliena | Ohio State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Phillips, Tim | Ohio State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Disalle, Michael | Ohio State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Fleagle, Josh | Ohio State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hillmer, Steffen | Ohio State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| McHugh, Matt | Ohio State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Williams, Rowan | Ohio State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Harrison, Sammy | Oregon State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ackman, Alyson | Penn State | Women | DI | First Team |
| Fittin, Carolyn | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Karr, Caitlyn | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Powers, Mackenzie | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Shishkoff, Gabrielle | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Sinatro, Haley | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Siverling, Megan | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Sowinski, Katelyn | Penn State | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ryan, Shane | Penn State | Men | DI | First Team |
| Austin, Shane | Penn State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hauser, John | Penn State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Savoy, Nate | Penn State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Schuehler, Andy | Penn State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Wilson, James | Penn State | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Swanson, Chris | Pennsylvania | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Boyce, Elizabeth | Princeton | Women | DI | First Team |
| Cabassol, Michelle | Purdue | Women | DI | First Team |
| Tweardy, MacKenzie | Purdue | Women | DI | First Team |
| Rogers, Layne | Purdue | Men | DI | First Team |
| Bissett, Jamie | Purdue | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Cox, Nathan | Purdue | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Dias, Lyam | Purdue | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Scott, Nicole | Rutgers | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Apostalon, Anika | San Diego St | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bailey, Chelsea | San Diego St | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Dalcamo, Maddy | San Diego St | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Macklin, Mikaela | San Diego St | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Weisz, Whitney | San Diego St | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| El Kamash, Marwan | South Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Flach, Michael | South Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Leithold, Kevin | South Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Rodriguez, Gerard | South Carolina | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Carlson, Kasey | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Chenault, Chelsea | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Gardell, Stina | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Ishimatsu, Haley | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Stenkvist, Henriette | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Swenson, Evan | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Tosky, Jasmine | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Wilk, Kasia | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Hawthorne, Meghan | Southern Cal | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kropp, Andrea | Southern Cal | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Stewart, Kendyl | Southern Cal | Women | DI | First Team |
| Carter, Dylan | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Colupaev, Dimitri | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Condorelli, Santo | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Davis, Maclin | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Lujan-Rivera, Sergio | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Malone, Reed | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Quintero, Cristian | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Spinazzola, Luca | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Wagner, Jack | Southern Cal | Men | DI | First Team |
| Bloch, Chase | Southern Cal | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Zhang, Kaixuan | Southern Illinois | Women | DI | First Team |
| Erasmus, Marne | Southern Methodist | Women | DI | First Team |
| Nicholas, Tara-Lynn | Southern Methodist | Women | DI | First Team |
| Arcila, Isabella | Southern Methodist | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Nicol, Rachel | Southern Methodist | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Rangelova, Nina | Southern Methodist | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Anderson, Julia | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| DiRado, Maya | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Haase, Sarah | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Lee, Felicia | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Neal, Lia | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Olsen, Katie | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Schaefer, Maddy | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Stafford, Nicole | Stanford | Women | DI | First Team |
| Clay, Alexandra | Stanford | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Haase, Sarah | Stanford | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Taylor, Andie | Stanford | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Thayer, Annemarie | Stanford | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Cosgarea, Drew | Stanford | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ipsen, Kristian | Stanford | Men | DI | First Team |
| Kremer, Tom | Stanford | Men | DI | First Team |
| Nolan, David | Stanford | Men | DI | First Team |
| Stephens, Thomas | Stanford | Men | DI | First Team |
| Black, Connor | Stanford | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Christensen, Bradley | Stanford | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Pickard, Chris | Stanford | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Thomson, Danny | Stanford | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bruens, Harper | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Gendron, Lindsay | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Hannis, Molly | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Johnson, Faith | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Lamp, Victoria | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| McNeilis, Kate | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Solernou, Lauren | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Thompson, Cherelle | Tennessee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Griffith, Mary | Tennessee | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lehane, Sean | Tennessee | Men | DI | First Team |
| Percy, Luke | Tennessee | Men | DI | First Team |
| Rairden, Sam | Tennessee | Men | DI | First Team |
| Robles-Rodriguez, Mauricio | Tennessee | Men | DI | First Team |
| Tillman, Troy | Tennessee | Men | DI | First Team |
| Aberg Ledjstrom, Gustav | Tennessee | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Prono, Renato | Tennessee | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Slater, Tristan | Tennessee | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ivory-Ganja, Emma | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Jaques, Gretchen | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Lobb, Ellen | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Moldenhauer, Lily | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Taylor, Maren | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Wong, Brynne | Texas | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bromberg, Samantha | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Cox, Madisyn | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hooper, Alexandra | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Karosas, Tasija | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Leneave, Kelsey | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Tucker, Samantha | Texas | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bowersox, Cory | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Conger, Jack | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Cooper, Tripp | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Darmody, Kip | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ellis, Matthew | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Ganiel, Imri | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Glass, Will | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Hixon, Michael | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Lewis, Sam | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Licon, Will | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Murray, John | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Weir, Caleb | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Youngquist, Clay | Texas | Men | DI | First Team |
| Anderson, Mark | Texas | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Gustafson, Aaron | Texas | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Murphy, Pat | Texas | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Adams, Cammile | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Benjamin, Kelli | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bosma, Sammie | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Dittmer, Erica | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Henry, Sarah | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Ibanez, Lili | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Larson, Breeja | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| McElhany, Caroline | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| McGregor, Ashley | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Miller, Paige | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| Oliver, Meredith | Texas A&M | Women | DI | First Team |
| McMahon, Sycerika | Texas A&M | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Frank, Simon | Texas A&M | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Burke, Kaitlin | Towson | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Ward, Andrea | UC-Santa Barbara | Women | DI | First Team |
| Baker, Lauren | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kinnear, Katie | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Mack, Linnea | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Murphy, Kathryn | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Quah, Ting Wen | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Senko, Anna | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Tarazona, Noelle | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| White, Madison | UCLA | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Herrington, Katelyne | UNLV | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Lameynardie, Sam | UNLV | Men | DI | First Team |
| Paco Pedroni, Tom | UNLV | Men | DI | First Team |
| Passos, Gui | UNLV | Men | DI | First Team |
| Virva, Dillon | UNLV | Men | DI | First Team |
| Gremizzi, Giacomo | UNLV | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Machado, Henrique | UNLV | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Szele, David | UNLV | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Colleou, Stina | Utah | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Merry, Kersten | Utah | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Swartz, Traycie | Utah | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Purss, Josiah | Utah | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| McClellan, Emily | UW-Milwaukee | Women | DI | First Team |
| Bartholomew, Courtney | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Borgersen, Hanne | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Kenney, Caroline | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Lloyd, Emily | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Naurath, Rachel | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Simon, Laura | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Smith, Leah | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Williamson, Ellen | Virginia | Women | DI | First Team |
| Cavalier, Meredith | Virginia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Jones, Kaitlyn | Virginia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Rauth, Shannon | Virginia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Thomas, Ellen | Virginia | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kolod, JB | Virginia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Kaeser, Yannick | Virginia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Papendick, Luke | Virginia | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Arnett, Kaylea | Virginia Tech | Women | DI | First Team |
| Paluszek, Weronika | Virginia Tech | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hawkins, Ryan | Virginia Tech | Men | DI | First Team |
| Shinholser, TJ | Virginia Tech | Men | DI | First Team |
| Higgins, Collin | Virginia Tech | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Bohman, Bryce | West Virginia | Men | DI | First Team |
| Schwingenschlogl, Fabian | Western Kentucky | Men | DI | First Team |
| Kinney, Chase | Wisconsin | Women | DI | First Team |
| Martin, Ivy | Wisconsin | Women | DI | First Team |
| Palm, Rebecka | Wisconsin | Women | DI | First Team |
| Van Hout, Aja | Wisconsin | Women | DI | First Team |
| Meinholz, Anna | Wisconsin | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Tamblyn, Annie | Wisconsin | Women | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Caldwell, Nicholas | Wisconsin | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Clifton, Cannon | Wisconsin | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hines, Tyler | Wisconsin | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Hutchins, Matt | Wisconsin | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Schafer, Nick | Wisconsin | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
| Kalms, Adam | Wyoming | Men | DI | Honorable Mention |
Give out a lot of certificates nowadays, but it is something for the swimmers when they turn 40 to look at the certificate and remember the good old days with their other memorabilia.
So to be listed as “All American”, only the competitors who swim in finals make it? What about the swimmers who swim in the morning relay sessions that end up qualifying for top 16 at night?
This isn’t being asked as slap at the international swimmers, but aren’t there swimmers on this “ALL AMERICAN” list that are not American? If so, it seems like the NCAA needs to find a new title to honor the top 16 swimmers. Perhaps just use the title TOP 16. All American should be as literal as the title. We all know that college swimming is not “all American” so let’s be honest with the titles.
USA – this list is published by the CSCAA, not the NCAA. Just wanted to make sure that was clear – the NCAA has no definition of ‘All-American.’
Technically, these types of recognition are “All-America” which is analgous to “All-Conference” or “All-State,” etc. Somehow the designation has become “All-American” in common usage – which is admittedly confusing because that sounds like its implies “only Americans.”
‘Merica… for ‘Mericans only.