The official nominations and details for the 2021 USA Swimming Golden Goggles Awards gala have been announced, and so it’s time for us to present our official SwimSwam ballot.
Note that these votes are based on who we think should win, not who we think will win, because the award winners are usually fairly predictable and mass-market.
The Golden Goggles Awards will be hosted in Miami on Decemebr 7.
2021 GOLDEN GOGGLES NOMINEES
Breakout Performer of the Year
This award is given to the athlete whose performance(s) stand out in relation to other years, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Bobby Finke
- Katie Grimes
- Lydia Jacoby (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Emma Weyant
This is a really tough one, because there were so many breakout performances in 2021 (a well-told story of the Tokyo 2020 Olympics). If I’m thinking through, I first cut down to two. One is Bobby Finke, who was on nobody’s radar internationally after some injuries, but who with matching Olympic gold medals in the 800 and 1500 may have single-handedly revived American men’s distance swimming. The other is Lydia Jacoby, who is such a great story to come out of Alaska and knock off one of the true juggernauts of world swimming, Lilly King, in her best event. Ultimately, the Jacoby story carries the day for us, the long trips to find a long course pool, the incredible improvement curve, and the upset.
Perseverance Award
This award is given to the athlete who came back from adversity, retirement, sickness, injury, etc., to have an outstanding performance(s) in 2021, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Annie Lazor
- Erica Sullivan
- Tom Shields (SwimSwam Official Selection)
This one is always a tricky award, because it feels like USA Swimming always has a different definition of ‘perseverance’ than we do.
Annie Lazor’s story is about the magic moments at the Olympic Trials and Olympic Games, where she won a bronze medal just 3 months after her father died, and especially how it played out through her relationship with her training partner Lilly King.
Erica Sullivan’s story is similar, having lost her father in 2017 when she was only 16 years old, and her grandather a year later in 2018, both to cancer. She has been outspoken about the mental health challenges this has caused her and the PTSD she’s experienced from the loss of a parent at such a young age.
Tom Shields’ story is about a suicide attempt in 2018 and a redemption path to an Olympic Team that not many thought he would make, and eventually a second Olympic gold medal on the men’s 400 medley relay (plus a second career as a short course superstar in the ISL and the World Cup).
All are worthy, and all play into narratives that have been at the forefront of sports, and the world, over the last two years.
For us, the winner is Shields because of the way that he has wilfully and purposely turned his redemption arc into one that is relateable and impactful for many, many young athletes, specifically. Giving him another platform to continue that work is a good thing.
Coach of the Year
This award is given to the coach whose athlete(s) performed at the highest level throughout the year, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Ron Aitken
- Jack Bauerle
- Todd DeSorbo
- Greg Meehan
- Anthony Nesty (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Gregg Troy
This one is really hard, though I’m a little disappointed that Lydia Jacoby’s coach Meghan O’Leary wasn’t nominated. A lot of the United States’ success this season was centered in a few groups, so that means there are a lot of coaches whose athletes did a lot of really fast things this year.
So when narrowing it down, the factors I consider most heavily are, which coaches’ athletes had their ‘best years ever’ in 2021 (because this is a single-year award, not a lifetime achievement award); which coaches’ athletes performed their best at the biggest meets; and which coaches showed a lot of depth to their athletes’ results.
Running through the list, Ron Aitken of Sandpiper had the most breakout swimmers and a women’s distance group with success like we haven’t seen from a single such group in decades; Jack Bauerle had a bounceback performance from Chase Kalisz to win the 400 IM, and he also put 4 other men on the team; Greg Meehan was the head coach of the women’s team and primary coach of Katie Ledecky, who while not quite at her best still won 2 gold and 2 silver medalist in Tokyo; Anthony Nesty, the coach of Bobby Finke and Kieran Smith who both parlayed big NCAA results into Olympic medals; and Gregg Troy, who is the primary coach of Caeleb Dressel, who had a monster Olympics, winning 5 gold medals and set 2 World Records.
The more complex case is Todd DeSorbo. If we’re focusing on the Olympics, which USA Swimming really wants everyone to do in their votes, 4 DeSorbo proteges (Paige Madden, Kate Douglass, Alex Walsh, and post-grad Catie DeLoof) made the U.S. Olympic Team. What’s more, even in a year where the U.S. had some struggles at the Olympics, they all came back with medals. Looking more holistically, he also led his women’s team to an overwhelming NCAA Championship performance in the most challenging of collegiate seasons. But the weakness in his resume for 2021 is that none of those swimmers won gold medals.
To me the debate comes down to DeSorbo versus Nesty. They both had success at multiple levels with multiple athletes.
I’ll take as a tiebreaker the work that Nesty did with some of the less-heralded members of the Florida team during the NCAA season. Adam Chaney had the best freshman sprint season since another Gator, Caeleb Dressel; he manufactured results like an 18.3 relay split from Eric Friese; and he coached Dillon Hillis to a runner-up NCAA finish in the 100 breaststroke. And all of the Olympic success came while merging to take over the women’s team in Florida, which added a mountain of new responsibilities onto his plate.
Relay Performance of the Year
This award is given to the best team relay performance, male or female. The performance considered must be a finals performance, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Women’s 4 x 200m Free Relay (2020 Olympic Games)
- Men’s 4 x 100m Free Relay (2020 Olympic Games)
- Men’s 4 x 100m Medley Relay (2020 Olympic Games) (SwimSwam Official Selection)
While I think the men’s 4x100m free relay was the better swim of the two, my choice for this award is the men’s 400 medley relay for a lot of reasons. For one, every member of that relay was embattled for one reason or another. Ryan Murphy and his comments about doping, Michael Andrew and the perception of not living up to expectations, Caeleb Dressel not swimming the 800 free relay, and Zach Apple for his split on the 800 free relay.
The U.S. needed this win on the last day of the meet, to launch into the three year cycle with some momentum, with some tailing positive energy, to prove that Michael Andrew doesn’t need to beat Adam Peaty to be good enough, to show that Caeleb Dressel is the singular dominant force in world swimming, to show that Zach Apple is still a reliable relay force for the USA. And to boot, they broke a relay record that has stood for 12 years – when many weren’t even sure if they could win. There was just so much emotion tied up in that last relay, I can’t help but choose it.
Female Race of the Year
This award is given to the female swimmer with the greatest single individual race of the year, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Lydia Jacoby – 100m Breaststroke (2020 Olympic Games) (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Katie Ledecky – 800m Freestyle (2020 Olympic Games)
- Katie Ledecky – 1500m Freestyle (2020 Olympic Games)
Katie Ledecky is still GOAT’ed, but Jacoby’s swim was a career-high for her, and Ledecky’s weren’t. For me, it’s a very simple conversation, and on singular race, that gives Jacoby the honor.
Male Race of the Year
This award is given to the male swimmer with the greatest single individual race of the year, with special emphasis on the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Caeleb Dressel – 100m Freestyle (2020 Olympic Games) (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Caeleb Dressel – 100m Butterfly (2020 Olympic Games)
- Bobby Finke – 800m Freestyle (2020 Olympic Games)
- Chase Kalisz – 400m Individual Medley (2020 Olympic Games)
It’s a little curious that Bobby Finke‘s 1500 free didn’t make this list along with the other individual gold medal-winning performances, though his 800 and that wild closing split.
But regardless, I don’t know how we can keep this away from Dressel after the Olympics he had. I think most votes will probably go for his World Record in the 100 fly, but I thought the 100 free and the matchup with Australian Kyle Chalmers was the better race.
Female Athlete of the Year
This award is given to the top female swimmer of the year with special emphasis on achievements at the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Lydia Jacoby
- Katie Ledecky (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Lilly King
- Regan Smith
As we zoom out for the ‘big ones,’ Ledecky, even without best times or World Records, still had more overall success than anyone on this list, winning the 800 and 1500 frees, taking silver in the 400 free, and taking silver in the 800 free relay. GOAT is still GOAT, who is still “Greatest of 2021” in the U.S.
Male Athlete of the Year
This award is given to the top male swimmer of the year with special emphasis on achievements at the 2020 Olympic Games.
- Bobby Finke
- Caeleb Dressel (SwimSwam Official Selection)
- Chase Kalisz
- Ryan Murphy
I don’t think there is an easier selection in this whole list. Dressel. 5 Olympic gold medals in 6 events. A few relay choices kept him from maybe climbing into the top 3 for “greatest single Olympics ever,” but I think it was at least a top 5 performance of all-time.
Caleb’s last 50 in the 100 free versus Finke’s last 50 in the 800 free. How much faster was Caleb’s??
Caeleb was 24.63
I don’t think CD would’ve gotten a 6th gold from the 4x200m free relay (given the UK’s gold and silver medalists in the 200m), BUT a 6th gold could’ve come from the 4x100m mixed medley relay. Just by not being the only team with a female on breast would’ve guaranteed a silver. (Was it a Ryan Murphy ego thing?) Regan Smith, Michael Andrew and CD — whoever the female free swimmer was and how she did would’ve determined gold or silver. (I’m less confident that staying with Huske on fly and CD on free would’ve bumped a silver to gold.)
The US is very close to winning using Smith Andrew Dressel Weitzeil if you take their best splits of the Olympics:
Smith – 57.64
Andrew – 58.49
Dressel – 49.03
Weitzeil – 52.49
Thing is those splits for Smith and Dressel are quite optimistic. In Smith’s case because based on her other swims it seems more likely she’d be in the 57.9-58.0 range. In Dressel’s case because he already had 100 fly and 50 free in the session and barely beat his flat start anchoring in free perhaps because of fatigue.
But yes they did basically flush a medal down the toilet. Probably the silver.
Anyway you seem positively obsessed with all things Dressel.
Todd DeSorbo is the COY imo…not only did all his swimmers at Olympics come home with a medal but they all did best times in Tokyo. None had much experience at this world stage yet they all raised their game after Trials when they went to the Olympics. So tough!
I don’t believe in spreading out the awards. The most deserving should get the award. If too close to call, then it should be a tie. And some this year are really too close to call.
I hate ties in awards. Because then the powers that be just start giving out lots of ties in order to preserve feelings, and the awards become watered down.
Sorry can’t vote for Desorbo. No gold medals = no COY. This is the US, gold is the standard.
“this is the US, gold is the standard” get your corny ahh outta here. bozo forgetting that desorbo is the coach that got the UVA women their first title and put four talented women on the olympic team.
To spread the awards out:
Breakout – Grimes
Female race – Jacoby
Male race – Finke
Female athlete – Ledecky
Male athlete – Dressel
if you give out awards just to “spread them out evenly” then whats even the point
after making it the “easier selection in this whole list”, what else does Dressel need to do to get Troy a Coach of the Year at Golden Goggle?
Ik that the mens relays were more impressive in that they won, but the womens 4 * 200 was just so magical to watch. Especially considering how ledecky rose to the challenge for team and country that she couldn’t meet individually. It was just such a powerful return to glory for her after a grueling week
Paige Maddens split too hope she gets the individual swim for Paris
Can’t go against the men’s 4x100m medley relay — gold *and* a WR *and* they didn’t lead throughout the race.
While I think all three nominees for the perseverance award are very worthy, I think this article misses the major issues Erica Sullivan has dealt with and spoken out about over the past couple of years.
You’re right, I had forgotten that part of her story. I’ve updated above.
Can’t really argue with any of these, though I’d maybe go Finke over Jacoby for breakout. (Especially if Jacoby’s getting best race for female, ‘why not spread the awards around a bit’ is my rationale.)
tHAT’S FAIR.
To spread the awards out:
Breakout – Grimes
Female race – Jacoby
Male race – Finke
Female athlete – Ledecky
Male athlete – Dressel
To win 2 individual events at the Olympics is ten times harder than winning one- it is a huge achievement…..look at swimmers like Liesel Jones or Libby Trickett who only managed one their whole career. Finke for me.
They added a new event so hard to compare to previous years. Previous years he would have only won one