Canada’s Brent Hayden is the latest swimmer to speak out against the light suspension given to Brazil’s Cesar Cielo in the wake of the his positive test for trace amounts of the diuretic furosemide, which can be used to conceal the presence of other steroids in urine tests.
At this point, though all of the athletes only received warnings and evacuation of results from the Maria Lenk Trophy, the meet at which they tested positive, Cielo is the only one to have truly escaped punishment. As we reported yesterday, Henrique Barbosa and Nicholas dos Santos lost their spots on the World Championships roster after those results were invalidated.
Hayden, who would be among Cielo’s biggest challengers in the sprint freestyle races in Shanghai this summer, became the latest in a long-line of athletes who have taken offense to the lightened suspense that the Brazilian federation (CBDA) handed out.
He said that if Cielo didn’t receive a longer suspension than Venezuelan Albert Subirats, then something is wrong in the sport of swimming — referring to the swimmer who in June received a one-year suspension after failing to properly log his whereabouts with FINA three times. Subirats sent his schedule to his national federation, but they failed to properly forward it to the international governing body.
Hayden would go on to say that “I wish I could say it’s a totally clean sport and that everyone is honest, but unfortunately we do not live in a world of great integrity.” He questioned why, if this was supposed to be an isolated incident, was the same substance found in the tests of three other athletes.
Cielo supporters would be quick to point out that it is not uncommon for other athletes to share the supplements of Cielo, who is much wealthier than his teammates and can better afford top-of-the-line products. The pills that Cielo is reported to have taken were Caffeine pills, which among other things he uses to fight jet-lag when traveling around the world.
Hayden is now one of a long list of athletes who have spoken out against the suspension. Frenchman Alain Bernard called the news “bad for the world of swimming,” though lacking context it was unclear whether or not he was referring to a positive test for the defending World and Olympic Champion, or the light suspension.
Via Twitter, Australia’s Geoff Huegill responded that “How do you only get off on a warning? WTF,” a sentiment that was echoed by several of his teammates.
With so many of Cielo’s competitors speaking out against him, if he’s allowed to compete in Shanghai, it will create a very interesting dynamic on the pool-deck. Cielo has never been entirely as popular as his performances might indicate, and historically it’s fueled his fire (for example, he and the Auburn program took a lot of heat for recruiting so many foreign athletes to the NCAA). Though he missed a few days of training while appearing before the CBDA panel, he’s back in the water.
In related news, all of CBDA’s documentation has been handed over to FINA for review prior to an appeal before the CAS.
BK, thanks, just saw it. You’ve done great job with this now my favorite swimming site!
Thanks! Appreciate it!
The FINA Statement in full:
Lausanne (SUI), July 6, 2011 – FINA has decided to appeal before the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) the decisions of the Doping Panel of the Brazilian Aquatic Sports Confederation in the matters of positive doping tests to the substance Furosemide for the swimmers Cesar Cielo Filho, Henrique Barbosa, Nicholas Santos and Vinicius Waked.
The appeals will be based on the elements in file at this stage. In any event, it will be up to the CAS Panel to issue a decision in accordance with the FINA Doping Control Rules.
The athletes are presently not suspended and the appeal will, in principle, have no effect of suspending their right to participate to events pending… Read more »
If only CBDA had given a few months of suspension right after Maria Lenk, all this wouldn’t have had to happen.
I’m surprised theswimmercircle has not oublished the latest news: FINA (and maybe WADA) decides to take the case to CAS. From swimnews:
Comment: Today we heard news that FINA (WADA may also do so) intends to challenge Brazil’s decision to impose the minimum penalty possible – warnings – on four swimmers, including Olympic and world champion Cesar Cielo, after they tested positive for furosemide, a diuretic on the list of banned substance for its ability to serve as a masking agent for other drugs prohibited in sport. The case is to go before the Court of Arbitration for Sport if all parties agree that a swift final ruling is in everyone’s interests at a time when the world championships loom.
Posted the news about an hour and a half ago:
http://theswimmerscircle.com/blog/featured/press-release-fina-officially-announces-intent-to-appeal-doping-case-to-cas/
what a cluster. Subirats got screwed. his federation should be penalized but he should not. As for Cielo and his crew: I tend to believe him about the cross contamination, but only if the claim is actually true that the Brazilian federation was able to show that there was no masking of another drug. That finding needs to be verified, and then all 4 athletes need to be treated equally.
Why a picture of Ricky Berens?
Hmmm, that was some glitch in our platform…try refreshing, it should be fixed.